Okay, let’s be real — The Summer I Turned Pretty has taken over our summer watchlists, and we’re all hooked on the Fisher brothers drama. If you’ve seen the show on Amazon Prime, you already know the question on everyone’s mind: Is Belly going to end up with Conrad or Jeremiah? The fandom is split right down the middle, and the debates online are getting heated. So let’s break down the Fisher brother endgame drama.
Team Conrad
Conrad is Belly’s first love — the moody, brooding older brother who stole her heart years ago. He’s mysterious, complicated, and has those quiet moments that make you melt. Their connection feels deep, almost like fate, and a lot of fans can’t shake the idea that Conrad and Belly are meant to be.
Why fans ride for Conrad:
- He’s Belly’s day-one crush.
- Their chemistry is undeniable.
He’s the “soulmate” type that makes for a swoon-worthy love story.
Team Jeremiah
Then there’s Jeremiah — sunshine, flirty, fun-loving, and always ready to make Belly laugh. He’s easy to love because he doesn’t play games. He puts his feelings out there, and his relationship with Belly feels lighter, healthier, and drama-free compared to the Conrad rollercoaster.
Why fans love Jeremiah:
- He’s funny, charming, and sweet.
- His love for Belly feels more stable and drama-free.
He’s the type you can picture in a real, everyday relationship.
The Debate
Social media is basically a warzone every time new episodes drop. #TeamConrad and #TeamJeremiah trend constantly, and honestly? The show does such a good job making you root for both that you might switch teams every other episode. One moment Conrad’s breaking your heart with his quiet looks, the next Jeremiah’s winning you over with his playful charm.
Endgame?
If you’ve read Jenny Han’s books, you might know how things play out, but the show is keeping everyone guessing. And honestly, that’s the fun of it. The real magic of The Summer I Turned Pretty is watching Belly figure out who she is, what she wants, and how love changes everything.
Whether you’re die-hard #TeamConrad or loyal to #TeamJeremiah, there’s no denying this is one of the juiciest love triangles we’ve had in a long time. So tell us — which Fisher brother is YOUR endgame?
